Best Car Insurance Companies for Drivers With Low Credit Scores

Finding affordable car insurance with a low credit score can be challenging in the United States. In many states, insurance companies may use credit information to calculate a credit-based insurance score, which can influence how they evaluate risk and determine premiums.

However, a low traditional credit score does not automatically mean you will be denied car insurance or that every insurer will charge you more. State laws, driving history, location, vehicle type, coverage choices, and the insurer’s own pricing model all matter.

Companies such as GEICO, Progressive, State Farm, Allstate, and The General are worth comparing when shopping for auto insurance. But there is no single company that is cheapest for every driver with poor credit. The best option depends on your state and personal circumstances.

Best car insurance companies for drivers with low credit scores in the USA, featuring GEICO, State Farm, Progressive, Allstate, safe-driving programs, discounts, and premium comparison tips.

This guide compares insurers and driving-discount programs, explains how credit-based insurance scores work, identifies states that restrict their use, and shares practical ways to find more affordable coverage.

Table of Contents

Can You Get Car Insurance With a Low Credit Score?

Yes. You can generally shop for car insurance even if you have a low credit score. A low score does not automatically make you ineligible for coverage.

In states where credit-based insurance scoring is permitted, an insurer may use credit information as one factor when evaluating an application or calculating a premium. Other factors can include:

  • Driving record and previous accidents
  • Claims history
  • State and ZIP code
  • Vehicle make, model, age, and value
  • Annual mileage
  • Coverage limits and deductibles
  • Insurance history and applicable discounts

The rules differ by state. Some states prohibit credit-based insurance scoring for auto insurance, while others restrict how insurers can use it.

It is also important to understand that a traditional credit score and a credit-based insurance score are not the same thing. They may use information from your credit history, but they are designed to predict different outcomes.

Credit Score vs. Credit-Based Insurance Score: What’s the Difference?

A traditional credit score helps lenders estimate how likely you are to repay borrowed money. A credit-based insurance score uses certain credit-report information to help insurers estimate the likelihood of an insurance loss.

FeatureTraditional credit scoreCredit-based insurance score
Main purposeEstimate credit repayment riskEstimate insurance loss risk
Common usersBanks, lenders, credit card issuersInsurance companies
Information usedCredit history and other scoring factorsSelected information from credit history
Main applicationLoan and credit decisionsInsurance underwriting and pricing where permitted
Scoring modelDepends on the credit scoring providerDepends on the insurer and scoring model

An insurer does not necessarily use the same FICO score that a bank uses when reviewing a loan application.

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) explains that credit-based insurance scores are designed to estimate the likelihood of future insurance losses, not whether someone will repay a loan.

Does a low credit score always mean expensive car insurance?

No. The effect depends on state regulations and the insurer’s pricing model. Your driving record, location, vehicle, coverage, and other factors may have a significant influence on the final premium.

Best Car Insurance Companies to Compare if You Have Low Credit

There is no universally cheapest insurer for drivers with low credit. Instead of relying on a national ranking, compare quotes from multiple companies using the same coverage limits and deductible.

The following insurers are worth including in your comparison.

1. GEICO

GEICO is a major U.S. auto insurer offering online quotes and several potential discounts.

Why compare GEICO?

  • Online quote and policy-management tools
  • Discounts for eligible drivers
  • Multi-vehicle and other qualifying policy discounts
  • DriveEasy usage-based insurance in participating locations

Best for: Drivers who prefer online quotes and want to compare available discounts.

What to check: Ask whether credit information is used in pricing in your state and compare the final premium with equivalent coverage from other insurers.

Official website: GEICO

2. State Farm

State Farm offers auto insurance through its agent network and provides eligible customers with several discount opportunities.

Why compare State Farm?

  • Local agent support
  • Multi-policy and other qualifying discounts
  • Drive Safe & Save usage-based insurance program
  • Multiple coverage options

Best for: Drivers who prefer working with an insurance agent and want to review available discounts.

What to check: Ask about eligibility for Drive Safe & Save and whether your state and driving habits make participation worthwhile.

Official website: State Farm

3. Progressive

Progressive is another insurer worth comparing, particularly if you are interested in usage-based insurance.

Its Snapshot program evaluates driving behavior and other driving information to determine whether a participating customer qualifies for a discount. Program availability and pricing effects vary by state.

Why compare Progressive?

  • Online quote tools
  • Snapshot usage-based insurance program
  • Multiple payment and coverage options
  • Discounts for eligible customers

Best for: Drivers interested in comparing traditional pricing with a usage-based insurance option.

What to check: Snapshot may not be available in every state or situation. Progressive also states that some drivers may see their rates increase based on driving data.

Official website: Progressive

4. Allstate

Allstate offers several auto insurance products and discounts, including its Drivewise program in eligible locations.

Why compare Allstate?

  • Drivewise driving-based program
  • Multiple coverage options
  • Potential multi-policy discounts
  • Local agent support

Best for: Drivers who want to compare traditional insurance coverage with available driving-based discount programs.

What to check: Review the program’s availability, privacy terms, eligibility rules, and possible effect on your premium before enrolling.

Official website: Allstate

5. The General

The General is another company drivers can include when shopping for auto insurance, particularly if they have difficulty finding coverage through other insurers.

Its availability and eligibility criteria depend on the applicant’s state and circumstances.

Why compare The General?

  • Online quote options
  • Coverage options for eligible drivers
  • An additional quote to compare against larger national insurers

Best for: Drivers who want to explore another insurance quote after comparing other companies.

What to check: Do not assume that The General will automatically accept every driver with poor credit or offer a lower premium. Compare its coverage, fees, payment requirements, and final price with other quotes.

Official website: The General

Comparison of Car Insurance Companies

Use this table as a starting point when requesting quotes.

Insurance companyFeature worth comparingWhat to verify
GEICOOnline quotes and DriveEasyState availability and discounts
State FarmAgent support and Drive Safe & SaveProgram eligibility and pricing
ProgressiveSnapshotWhether driving data can affect renewal pricing
AllstateDrivewiseAvailability, terms, and privacy
The GeneralAdditional quote optionEligibility, payment terms, and coverage

Important: This is a comparison list, not a ranking of the cheapest companies for low-credit drivers. No insurer should be described as the best for poor credit without current, state-specific rate data using comparable driver profiles and coverage.

How Much Does a Low Credit Score Increase Car Insurance Costs?

There is no single nationwide premium increase that applies to every driver with poor credit.

The difference depends on:

  • The state where you live
  • Whether credit-based insurance scoring is permitted
  • The insurer’s scoring model
  • Your driving history
  • Your vehicle and annual mileage
  • Your coverage limits and deductible
  • Other underwriting and rating factors

For example, two drivers with similar vehicles and driving records may receive different quotes because they live in different ZIP codes or apply through different insurers.

Illustrative Example: Comparing Two Insurance Quotes

Imagine a driver receives the following quotes for the same vehicle and coverage:

QuoteAnnual premium
Insurer A$2,100
Insurer B$2,450
Insurer C$2,280

In this hypothetical example, Insurer A costs $350 less per year than Insurer B.

However, this does not prove that Insurer A offers better rates to everyone with a low credit score. The difference could reflect the insurer’s overall pricing model, coverage terms, discounts, or other factors.

Always compare quotes for the same liability limits, comprehensive and collision coverage, deductibles, and optional benefits.

States Where Credit-Based Insurance Scoring Is Restricted or Prohibited

State regulations can make a significant difference to how credit information affects auto insurance.

Some states prohibit insurers from using credit information in auto insurance pricing, while others restrict how it may be used.

California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan have broad prohibitions on using credit-based insurance information for personal auto insurance rating. Other states, including Maryland, have important restrictions on how insurers may use credit history.

StateGeneral position on credit-based auto insurance scoring
CaliforniaCredit-based insurance scoring is prohibited for auto insurance rating
HawaiiCredit ratings cannot be used to determine auto insurance rates
MassachusettsCredit information cannot be used for private passenger auto insurance rating or underwriting
MichiganState law prohibits use of credit information in personal auto insurance underwriting and rating
MarylandCredit history use is restricted, including limits on certain underwriting and renewal decisions

This is not a complete list of state insurance regulations. Other states also impose restrictions, disclosures, and consumer protections.

Rules can change, so check with your state insurance department before making a decision.

Official resources:

How to Lower Car Insurance Costs With Bad Credit

If credit information affects your premium in your state, you can still take practical steps to find more affordable coverage.

1. Compare Quotes From Multiple Insurers

This is one of the most important steps.

Different insurance companies use different underwriting and pricing models. A company that offers a high quote for one driver may offer a more competitive price to another.

Request quotes from at least three insurers and compare the same:

  • Liability limits
  • Comprehensive and collision coverage
  • Deductibles
  • Uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage
  • Optional benefits
  • Policy duration

Do not choose a policy based only on its advertised starting price.

2. Ask About Usage-Based Insurance

Some insurers offer programs that evaluate driving behavior, mileage, or other driving information.

Examples include:

  • Progressive Snapshot
  • State Farm Drive Safe & Save
  • Allstate Drivewise
  • GEICO DriveEasy

These programs may reward eligible safe-driving behavior, but their rules differ.

Before enrolling, check:

  • Whether the program is available in your state
  • What driving information is collected
  • Whether participation can increase your premium
  • How discounts are calculated
  • Whether your driving habits are likely to qualify for savings

A usage-based program does not automatically ignore your credit history. It may simply provide another factor that influences your insurance price.

3. Consider a Higher Deductible

A deductible is the amount you generally pay toward a covered comprehensive or collision claim before your insurer pays the remaining eligible amount.

Choosing a higher deductible may reduce your premium, but it also means you could pay more out of pocket after an accident.

For example, compare these hypothetical options:

DeductibleAnnual premium
$500$1,800
$1,000$1,650

In this example, choosing the $1,000 deductible reduces the annual premium by $150.

However, you would need to pay more toward a covered claim. Choose a deductible you could realistically afford.

4. Ask About Available Discounts

Insurance companies may offer discounts for eligible customers.

Common examples include:

  • Multi-policy discounts
  • Multi-vehicle discounts
  • Safe-driving discounts
  • Good-student discounts
  • Defensive-driving course discounts
  • Vehicle safety feature discounts
  • Paperless billing
  • Automatic payment
  • Paid-in-full options

Discounts vary by insurer, state, and eligibility. Ask your agent or insurer which discounts are available and whether they can be combined.

5. Review Your Coverage

If you own an older vehicle with a relatively low market value, compare the cost of comprehensive and collision coverage with the potential benefit.

However, do not remove coverage without considering your financial situation.

If your vehicle is financed or leased, your lender or leasing company may require comprehensive and collision coverage.

Also, do not reduce liability coverage below your state’s legal requirements or a level that adequately protects your financial interests.

6. Maintain Continuous Insurance Coverage

Allowing your auto insurance policy to lapse can create additional problems.

Depending on your state and circumstances, a coverage gap may affect your future insurance options or premium. Driving without required insurance can also result in fines, registration issues, or license-related penalties.

If your current policy is becoming unaffordable, compare alternative coverage before cancelling it.

7. Review Your Credit Reports for Errors

If your insurer uses credit information where permitted, inaccurate or outdated information could affect the result.

Review your credit reports and dispute errors with the relevant credit reporting agency.

You can obtain your reports through:

AnnualCreditReport.com

If an insurer tells you that credit information contributed to an adverse insurance decision, review the notice and ask the insurer how to obtain information about the credit reporting agency and factors involved.

What Is a Credit-Based Insurance Score Based On?

Credit-based insurance scores may use selected information from a consumer’s credit history.

Depending on the scoring model, relevant credit characteristics may include:

  • Payment history
  • Outstanding debt
  • Length of credit history
  • Recent applications for credit
  • Types of credit accounts
  • Collection or derogatory information

However, insurance scoring models are not identical across providers. There is no universal formula or fixed percentage assigned to each factor.

A credit-based insurance score is also not designed to measure your income, occupation, or driving ability.

Insurers generally consider credit information alongside other factors when it is legally permitted.

Best Car Insurance Options if You Have No Credit History

Having no credit history is different from having a poor credit history.

A person with no credit history may be a student, a young adult, a recent immigrant, or someone who has never used traditional credit products.

In states where credit-based insurance scoring is permitted, an insurer may have different procedures for applicants with limited or no credit information. Some state laws also restrict how the absence of credit information can be treated.

If you have no credit history:

  1. Request quotes from multiple insurers.
  2. Ask how the company handles applicants with limited credit information.
  3. Compare insurers that offer usage-based driving programs.
  4. Ask about discounts for safe driving, low mileage, and vehicle safety features.
  5. Review your coverage and deductible options.

Do not assume that having no credit history automatically makes you a high-risk driver.

Telematics Programs: Can Safe Driving Help Lower Your Premium?

Telematics programs use driving-related information to help insurers assess driving habits and, in some cases, calculate discounts.

Depending on the program, information may include:

  • Mileage
  • Braking behavior
  • Acceleration
  • Time of day
  • Phone use while driving
  • Other driving-related data

Here are examples of programs offered by major insurers:

InsurerProgramWhat to check
ProgressiveSnapshotDriving behavior, mileage and state availability
State FarmDrive Safe & SaveEligibility and driving-data requirements
AllstateDrivewiseProgram terms and potential savings
GEICODriveEasyAvailability and participation rules

These programs are not guaranteed ways to lower your premium. Some may increase rates for certain driving patterns or have restrictions based on location.

Review the privacy policy and program terms before enrolling.

Monthly Payment Plans for Drivers With Low Credit

If paying an entire annual premium upfront is difficult, ask insurers about available payment plans.

Depending on the company and state, you may be able to pay monthly, quarterly, or through another installment schedule.

Before choosing a payment option, compare:

  • Initial down payment
  • Monthly installment amount
  • Installment fees
  • Automatic payment requirements
  • Late payment charges
  • Cancellation rules

Paying the full premium upfront may reduce certain fees with some insurers, but it is not automatically cheaper in every case.

Choose a payment schedule that you can manage consistently.

What Happens If Your Car Insurance Policy Lapses?

A policy lapse occurs when your car insurance coverage ends and you do not have replacement coverage in place.

A lapse can create several problems:

  • You may be driving without legally required coverage.
  • You could face state penalties.
  • You may have difficulty obtaining affordable coverage later.
  • Some insurers may consider prior insurance history when calculating a quote.
  • You may be personally responsible for covered losses that occur while uninsured.

If you cannot afford your current policy, compare alternative coverage before the cancellation date.

Minimum liability insurance may satisfy your state’s legal requirements, but it may not provide enough financial protection after a serious accident.

A Practical 90-Day Plan to Find More Affordable Car Insurance

You do not need to wait months to start comparing insurance prices. You can begin reviewing your options immediately.

Days 1–30: Compare Your Current Coverage

  • Request quotes from at least three insurers.
  • Compare the same coverage limits and deductibles.
  • Check whether credit information is used in your state.
  • Review available discounts.
  • Avoid allowing your current policy to lapse.

Days 31–60: Review Your Driving and Financial Profile

  • Check your driving record for errors.
  • Review your credit reports for inaccurate information.
  • Consider an eligible usage-based insurance program.
  • Review whether your deductible is affordable.
  • Ask your insurer whether additional discounts are available.

Days 61–90: Reassess Your Policy

  • Compare your current premium with other available quotes.
  • Ask whether your insurer can review updated information.
  • Check whether your driving program has produced a discount.
  • Review your coverage needs and payment schedule.

There is no guarantee that your premium will fall within 90 days. The purpose of this plan is to help you identify realistic savings opportunities and avoid paying more than necessary.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I get car insurance with a low credit score?

Yes. A low credit score does not automatically prevent you from obtaining car insurance. However, in states where credit-based insurance scoring is permitted, it may influence your premium or underwriting decision alongside other factors.

2. What credit score is considered bad for car insurance?

There is no universal credit-score threshold that defines a bad credit-based insurance score. Insurers may use different scoring models, and a traditional FICO score is not necessarily the score used for insurance pricing.

3. Which car insurance company is cheapest for drivers with low credit?

There is no single cheapest insurer for every driver. GEICO, Progressive, State Farm, Allstate, and The General are companies you can compare, but prices vary by state, driver profile, vehicle, and coverage.

4. Which states prohibit credit-based auto insurance scoring?

California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan have broad prohibitions on using credit information for personal auto insurance rating. Other states impose restrictions on how credit information can be used.

5. Can I get car insurance without a credit history?

Yes. Having no credit history does not automatically prevent you from obtaining car insurance. Ask insurers how they handle applicants with limited or unavailable credit information in your state.

6. Does Progressive Snapshot ignore credit scores?

Snapshot is a usage-based insurance program that evaluates driving information. It does not mean Progressive automatically ignores credit information in states where credit-based insurance scoring is permitted.

7. Can improving my credit score lower my car insurance premium?

It may help in states where insurers can use credit-based insurance scoring. However, the effect depends on the insurer’s model and other rating factors. Ask your insurer whether it reviews updated credit information and when.

8. Does checking car insurance quotes affect my credit score?

Requesting an insurance quote generally does not affect your traditional credit score in the same way as applying for a loan or credit card. However, insurers may access consumer information for underwriting where permitted. Ask the company what type of inquiry it uses.

9. Can an insurance company deny coverage because of bad credit?

The rules depend on state law. In many states, credit information cannot be the sole reason for denying, cancelling, or refusing to renew a policy. Some states prohibit its use in personal auto insurance underwriting or rating altogether. Other underwriting factors and state-specific protections apply.

10. Does paying car insurance in full reduce the premium?

Some insurers offer paid-in-full or other payment-related discounts, while others may simply charge fewer installment fees. Compare the total cost of each payment option before choosing.

11. Does letting car insurance lapse affect future premiums?

A lapse may affect future insurance options and pricing, depending on state rules and the insurer’s underwriting practices. It can also create legal and financial risks if you drive without required coverage.

12. Can safe driving habits reduce car insurance costs?

Yes, safe driving may help you qualify for discounts or usage-based insurance savings. However, program rules differ, and some programs can increase rates for certain driving patterns.

Final Thoughts about the car insurance for low credit score

Having a low credit score does not mean you have to accept the first car insurance quote you receive.

The most practical approach is to compare multiple insurers, review your state’s rules, check available discounts, and choose coverage that fits your financial situation.

GEICO, Progressive, State Farm, Allstate, and The General are possible starting points for your comparison, but the cheapest option depends on your location, driving history, vehicle, and policy requirements.

If your state allows credit-based insurance scoring, review your credit reports for errors and ask insurers how credit information affects your premium. You can also explore usage-based programs, higher deductibles where affordable, and payment options that fit your budget.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute insurance, financial, or legal advice. Auto insurance rates, eligibility, credit-based insurance scoring rules, discounts, and coverage requirements vary by state and insurer. Always review the current policy terms and consult your state insurance department or licensed insurance professional for guidance.

Authoritative Sources

GEICO – Car Insurance Discounts

National Association of Insurance Commissioners – Credit-Based Insurance Scores

Illinois Department of Insurance – How Insurers Use Credit

New York Department of Financial Services – Auto Insurance Consumer Resources

Massachusetts General Laws – Credit Information and Private Passenger Auto Insurance

Progressive – Snapshot Program

Recommended Reads:

  1. Best Lenders for Low Credit Score USA
  2. Does Applying for a Credit Card Lower Your Credit Score?
  3. How to Lower Credit Utilization and Improve Your Credit Score
  4. 7 Best Credit Builder Apps in the USA That Can Boost Your Score Even If It’s Below 600
  5. 5 Reasons Why Rejected for Credit Card?
Spread the love